FANTASY FOOTBALL: CONSISTENTLY CONSISTENT RBs

Bob Lung, Staff Writer February 8, 2012

It’s one thing to be consistent during one season in Fantasy football. However, the consistently consistent players are the real Fantasy studs. These players are the ones that should be drafted in the early rounds of most drafts. A consistently consistent player has also remained consistently healthy, which is just as important as their statistical performance.

This week we will look at the consistently consistent running backs. The Top 40 most consistent running backs and the number of Quality Games Earned each year are listed below.

I’m going to break these Top 40 into four tiers, analyze each tier and provide some insight on the players within each tier.

Rank Player Name
2009
2010
2011
Total
1 Ray Rice
15
11
15
41
2 Maurice Jones-Drew
13
11
15
39
3 Adrian Peterson
16
12
9
37
4 Chris Johnson
14
10
12
36
5 Steven Jackson
12
13
11
36
6 LeSean McCoy
7
14
14
35
7 Frank Gore
11
10
11
32
8 Arian Foster
3
15
12
30
9 Matt Forte
8
10
11
29
10 Michael Turner
6
10
12
28
11 Rashard Mendenhall
9
11
8
28
12 Darren Sproles
6
7
14
27
13 LaDainian Tomlinson
10
10
6
26
14 Ahmad Bradshaw
3
12
10
25
15 Pierre Thomas
10
5
10
25
16 Fred Jackson
8
6
10
24
17 Cedric Benson
9
8
7
24
18 Jamaal Charles
9
14
1
24
19 Jonathan Stewart
8
4
10
22
20 Michael Bush
4
7
10
21
21 Marshawn Lynch
4
5
11
20
22 Reggie Bush
7
3
10
20
23 Darren McFadden
3
12
5
20
24 Joseph Addai
12
6
2
20
25 Mike Tolbert
2
9
8
19
26 Peyton Hillis
0
13
6
19
27 Felix Jones
5
8
6
19
28 Knowshon Moreno
10
8
1
19
29 Ryan Mathews
0
6
12
18
30 Brandon Jacobs
6
6
6
18
31 Willis McGahee
5
4
8
17
32 BenJarvus Green-Ellis
0
10
7
17
33 Tim Hightower
9
5
3
17
34 Thomas Jones
10
7
0
17
35 Chris Wells
6
2
8
16
36 DeAngelo Williams
9
1
6
16
37 Carnell Williams
9
6
1
16
38 Ricky Williams
11
4
1
16
39 Jahvid Best
0
10
5
15
40 Ryan Grant
12
0
3
15

Tier One: The Elite (Ranked 1 – 8)

First, let’s identify the Triple-Doubles group, which includes five of the top eight. They include Ray Rice, Maurice Jones-Drew, Chris Johnson, Steven Jackson and Frank Gore. Every Fantasy owner who had Rice and MJD on their team knows how well they did. However, it may surprise Fantasy owners to see Chris Johnson on this list after his poor start to the 2011 season. Gore and Jackson were on almost all of my teams in 2011, as they were great values in most of my drafts.

Adrian Peterson missed double-digits since he only played in 12 games. However, he still earned nine Quality Games in 2011. LeSean McCoy and Arian Foster have earned 28 and 27 Quality Games respectively over the past two seasons and would rank first and second as a result.

 

Tier Two: The Above Average (Ranked 9 – 15)

The second tier includes LaDainian Tomlinson, who is at the end of his career. He really should not be considered an option in the Fantasy mainstream any more.

Matt Forte, Michael Turner and Ahmad Bradshaw are all solid Fantasy backs. They have improved their consistency over the past couple of seasons with double-digit Quality Games each year.

Rashard Mendenhall would have joined the last group but injuries and poor performance dropped him down to only eight Quality Games in 2011. He should rebound in 2012, but I’m not sure I’ll be grabbing him for any of my teams.

Darren Sproles vaulted to nearly the top of the 2011 consistency standings and should be a top pick in PPR leagues in 2012. However, since half of his Quality Games were accrued this season, it’s hard to call him consistently consistent just yet.

 

Tier Three: The Average (Ranked 16 – 25)

This group is quite a menagerie of Fantasy players. Some are solid players like Marshawn Lynch, Reggie Bush, Fred Jackson, Jamaal Charles and Darren McFadden. Jackson was a perfect 10 for 10 in Quality Games until an injury ended his season. McFadden was also off to a good start until injuries did him in.

Players like Michael Bush and Jonathan Stewart showed off their consistency potential when given the chance this season.

Cedric Benson and Joseph Addai are players who used to be talented but are slowly becoming inconsistent and thus, forgotten on draft day.

 

Tier Four: The Others (Ranked 26 – 40)

The bottom tier includes players that need to be separated out and identified as top players from last season that should continue to improve on their 2011 success. These players include Ryan Mathews, Beanie Wells and Jahvid Best. Mathews really broke out in 2011, with 12 Quality Games. He ended the season near the top of the Fantasy rankings in both total points and consistency. Wells earned eight Quality Games and showed flashes of greatness before tailing off near the end of the season. Before his injury, Best was five for six for an 83-percent QSR in 2011, and he earned 10 Quality Games the season before. He’s going to be a great value pick in most drafts in 2012.

There are your most consistent running backs over the past three seasons. Keep this information handy as you prepare for your 2012 Fantasy drafts. Consistency is good but consistently consistent is great!

 

If you have any questions about the Quality Game Scores, you can email me at blung@rotoexperts.com. You can also follow me on Twitter.

Want to relive the key moments of the 2011 Fantasy Football season and scout players for 2012? NFL Rewind is your pass to all the game footage you want! Click here and make sure to enter the promo code ROTOEXPERTS for discounts up to 25 percent.

Get RotoExperts advice straight from your Android phone by downloading the app!

The best Roto news and advice comes straight to you from the RotoExperts right here!

Wake up every morning with RotoExperts on Sirius XM’s Fantasy Sports Radio channel. Listen live starting at 7 am ET as RotoExperts.com covers all Fantasy Sports and takes your calls on Sirius channel 210 and XM channel 87.  Also, don’t forget, I’ll be on every Friday mornings at 9:30 am.

Print Friendly