FANTASY FOOTBALL: QUALITY GAME SCORES

Bob Lung, Staff Writer December 28, 2011

Look at some of the top players this week and note that they are the same consistent players that got you to the Championship game and then gave you a title. If you’ve been following along with the Quality Game Scores this season and it helped you in bringing home a title please email me (blung@rotoexperts.com) and let me know. I always enjoy knowing that Quality Game Scores is bringing home titles to someone other than me. If this is your Championship week, then follow the same path that brought you here. Consistent Players. I hope everyone has a Blessed New Year and I look forward to helping you dominate again in 2012.

Jordy Nelson played a huge role in carrying his Fantasy owners to a Championship.  Photo Credit: Icon SMI

Consistency. Any educated Fantasy owner knows that you need your Fantasy Football players to be not only good, but also consistently good! It’s a proven fact that the more consistent your Fantasy players are throughout the season, the better the chance you’ll win. More wins equals playoffs, and playoffs can turn into championships! That’s why I’ll be here each week to help you identify the most consistent Fantasy Football players this season in your quest for a Fantasy championship.

Here is a quick recap for those unfamiliar with the Quality Game Scores. The Quality Game Score is the awarding of a Quality Game to a player each week when they exceed the average points scored in your league for that position. The more Quality Games a player is awarded each year, the more consistent that player is and the more beneficial they are to your Fantasy team.

The scoring method used will be one point per 20 yards passing and four points for passing touchdowns; one point per 10 yards rushing and receiving; one point per reception; and six points for any rushing/receiving touchdown.

So, let’s begin the review…

 

Quarterbacks – (Quality Game Factor – 17.44)

Quality Game Earners – Week 16

Rank Player
Team
Score
1 Aaron Rodgers
GB
35.95
2 Cam Newton
CAR
33.05
3 Tom Brady
NE
32.90
4 Matthew Stafford
DET
31.15
5 Drew Brees
NO
30.25
6 Matt Moore
MIA
25.60
7 Michael Vick
PHI
23.65
8 Josh Freeman
TB
23.10
9 Matt Ryan
ATL
22.35
10 Mark Sanchez
NYJ
22.20
11 Joe Webb
MIN
21.60
12 Rex Grossman
WAS
21.20
13 Andy Dalton
CIN
20.50
14 John Skelton
ARI
20.45
15 Matt Hasselbeck
TEN
19.70
16 Tim Tebow
DEN
18.65
17 Josh McCown
CHI
17.90

THE EXPECTED

The Top Five most consistent quarterbacks for the season were the Top Five highest scoring quarterbacks this week. Coincidence? Nope. These players got you to the championship game and did their best to earn you a title. Cam Newton is the biggest surprise by far but Matthew Stafford staying healthy all season is pretty huge too. Drew Brees breaks Dan Marino’s 23-year-old record for passing yards and yet still trails Aaron Rodgers in Fantasy points.

THE UNEXPECTED

Matt Moore has been a decent surprise in the second half of the 2011 season. He only has a 50 percent Quality Success Rate (QSR), but he earned those six over the last eight weeks. He could be a decent sleeper for next season. John Skelton continues to cause a quarterback controversy in Arizona as his QSR for the season is 71 percent and Kevin Kolb’s QSR is only 44 percent. Josh McCown was semi-retired and now has his first Quality Game of 2011.   

Here is a group of those bad surprises, quarterbacks who didn’t earn a Quality Game this week. Eli Manning failed his Fantasy owners for the second straight week.

Rank Player
Team
Score
19 Philip Rivers
SD
16.95
20 Joe Flacco
BAL
16.60
23 Eli Manning
NYG
14.15
24 Carson Palmer
OAK
13.85
26 Ryan Fitzpatrick
BUF
12.00

 

Consistency Leaders – YTD – Quarterbacks    

Player Name
Total Points
Rank
Total QG
Total GP
QSR
Aaron Rodgers
449.55
1
15
15
100%
Tom Brady
404.75
4
15
15
100%
Drew Brees
418.45
2
14
15
93%
Cam Newton
408.35
3
13
15
87%
Matthew Stafford
362.70
5
13
15
87%
Tim Tebow
222.45
18
10
12
83%
Matt Ryan
316.95
7
12
15
80%
Tony Romo
310.05
8
10
14
71%
John Skelton
119.00
32
5
7
71%
Eli Manning
318.30
6
10
15
67%
Philip Rivers
297.60
9
10
15
67%
Michael Vick
257.00
13
8
12
67%
Mark Sanchez
282.45
10
9
15
60%
Matt Schaub
189.85
22
6
10
60%
Carson Palmer
152.10
26
5
9
56%
Ben Roethlisberger
264.80
11
7
14
50%
Rex Grossman
187.70
23
6
12
50%
Matt Moore
185.05
24
6
12
50%
Jay Cutler
169.55
25
5
10
50%

One week to go and a perfect quarterback season is still in reach. Next week, both Aaron Rodgers and Tom Brady have a shot at it. Cam Newton could lose his third place ranking in overall points, as Brady is only four points behind. Check out the gap between fourth place and sixth place in total points. Yep, that’s right. A total of 86 points! The most disappointing quarterbacks lie in the 67 percent to 71 percent QSR. The foursome of Tony Romo, Philip Rivers, Eli Manning and Michael Vick have hurt a number of Fantasy teams with poor play and injuries.

 

Running Backs – (Quality Game Factor – 10.58)

Quality Game Earners – Week 16    

Rank Player
Team
Score
1 Arian Foster
HOU
26.40
2 Maurice Jones-Drew
JAX
24.40
3 Ray Rice
BAL
22.50
4 DeAngelo Williams
CAR
22.40
5 Rashard Mendenhall
PIT
22.10
6 C.J. Spiller
BUF
21.80
7 Marshawn Lynch
SEA
21.10
8 Kevin Smith
DET
20.10
9 Kahlil Bell
CHI
19.90
10 Ahmad Bradshaw
NYG
19.20
11 Jonathan Stewart
CAR
16.90
12 Darren Sproles
NO
16.90
13 Evan Royster
WAS
16.70
14 Frank Gore
SF
16.60
15 Reggie Bush
MIA
15.90
16 Dexter McCluster
KC
15.40
17 Steven Jackson
STL
14.70
18 Pierre Thomas
NO
13.70
19 Peyton Hillis
CLE
13.20
20 Adrian Peterson
MIN
13.20
21 LaDainian Tomlinson
NYJ
12.50
22 Michael Turner
ATL
11.50
23 Michael Bush
OAK
11.40
24 Isaac Redman
PIT
11.00
25 Toby Gerhart
MIN
10.90
26 Shonn Greene
NYJ
10.80

THE EXPECTED

Ray Rice came up big this week and took over the No. 1 spot in total points and consistency. Other consistent names like Maurice Jones-Drew, Steven Jackson, Darren Sproles and Frank Gore all earned Quality Games for their Fantasy owners’ championship game. These consistent players were on almost all of my teams. Some of the inconsistent players who let their Fantasy teams down were players like Chris Johnson, Ryan Mathews, Cedric Benson and Beanie Wells.

THE UNEXPECTED

C.J. Spiller may turn the Bills into a running powerhouse next season with him and Fred Jackson. Spiller earned three Quality Games out of his last four games. Kevin Smith looked healthy again and earned another Quality Game. He will make things tough for Jahvid Best next season. In what seems like the 27th running back in the Redskins system for this season, Evan Royster earned a Quality Game this week. Royster busted off 16.70 points in a PPR format and is just another back to keep in your mind next season or you can just ignore the Redskins carousel all together.

Below is a list of some of the top running backs that did not earn a Quality Game this week. As I mentioned above, some big names hurt their Fantasy owners this week. LeSean McCoy’s bad week was injury related, but a killer just the same.

Rank Player
Team
Score
27 Ryan Mathews
SD
10.40
30 Mike Tolbert
SD
10.10
31 Ryan Grant
GB
9.80
38 Cedric Benson
CIN
7.50
39 Chris Wells
ARI
7.10
46 Willis McGahee
DEN
6.40
49 Chris Johnson
TEN
5.60
50 LeSean McCoy
PHI
5.50
81 LeGarrette Blount
TB
1.10
82 BenJarvus Green-Ellis
NE
1.00

 

Consistency Leaders – YTD – Running Backs    

Player Name
Total Points
Rank
Total QG
Total GP
QSR
Ray Rice
336.90
1
14
15
93%
LeSean McCoy
329.40
2
14
15
93%
Maurice Jones-Drew
287.70
4
14
15
93%
Darren Sproles
253.40
5
13
15
87%
Matt Forte
222.70
8
11
12
92%
Arian Foster
306.10
3
11
13
85%
Steven Jackson
214.70
10
11
14
79%
Michael Turner
202.60
15
11
15
73%
Fred Jackson
210.60
13
10
10
100%
Ryan Mathews
238.60
6
10
14
71%
Marshawn Lynch
234.50
7
10
14
71%
Reggie Bush
221.20
9
10
15
67%
Michael Bush
213.60
11
10
15
67%
Chris Johnson
211.50
12
10
15
67%
Frank Gore
194.60
16
10
15
67%
Pierre Thomas
174.10
20
10
15
67%
Adrian Peterson
207.20
14
9
12
75%
Jonathan Stewart
177.80
19
9
15
60%
Ahmad Bradshaw
169.70
23
8
11
73%
Chris Wells
173.90
21
8
13
62%
Rashard Mendenhall
173.70
22
8
14
57%
Shonn Greene
187.00
18
8
15
53%
Mike Tolbert
191.40
17
7
14
50%
Willis McGahee
149.50
26
7
14
50%

McCoy’s injury knocked off his perfect season and now has put Ray Rice at the top of the list. Please note that MJD has also moved into a tie for first place in consistency. Of course, percentage-wise, Fred Jackson is still “perfect,” but I left him down in the ten Quality Games earned to reflect his overall season a little better. Just to see if you’re awake, note that only three backs have over 300 Fantasy points, Rice and McCoy are two of them. The other is Arian Foster who missed two games. His average Fantasy points per game is higher than Rice and McCoy. Remember this next year when you have the No. 1 pick, Foster is still the man.  

 

Wide Receiver – (Quality Game Factor – 11.05)

Quality Game Earners – Week 16   

Rank Player
Team
Score
1 Jordy Nelson
GB
29.50
2 Brandon Marshall
MIA
28.60
3 Julio Jones
ATL
26.80
4 Wes Welker
NE
26.50
5 Victor Cruz
NYG
25.40
6 Reggie Wayne
IND
24.60
7 Roddy White
ATL
23.70
8 Larry Fitzgerald
ARI
22.50
9 Malcom Floyd
SD
21.50
10 Percy Harvin
MIN
21.40
11 Marques Colston
NO
21.10
12 James Jones
GB
21.00
13 Calvin Johnson
DET
20.20
14 Dwayne Bowe
KC
20.00
15 Jabar Gaffney
WAS
19.70
16 Denarius Moore
OAK
19.40
17 Brandon LaFell
CAR
19.30
18 Jeremy Maclin
PHI
18.20
19 Donte’ Stallworth
WAS
16.90
20 DeSean Jackson
PHI
16.70
21 Robert Meachem
NO
16.50
22 Damian Williams
TEN
16.30
23 Nate Burleson
DET
15.40
24 Jerome Simpson
CIN
15.20
25 Roy Williams
CHI
14.10
26 Miles Austin
DAL
14.00
27 Michael Crabtree
SF
13.50
28 Andre Roberts
ARI
13.50
29 Steve Johnson
BUF
13.20
30 Davone Bess
MIA
12.90
31 Deion Branch
NE
12.70
32 Mike Wallace
PIT
12.20
33 Dez Bryant
DAL
12.20
34 Demaryius Thomas
DEN
11.60
35 Brian Hartline
MIA
11.20
36 Nate Washington
TEN
11.10
37 Jarett Dillard
JAX
11.10

THE EXPECTED

As expected, the Falcons’ dynamic duo of Roddy White and Julio Jones combined for over 52 Fantasy points and both earned Quality Games versus the Saints on Monday Night. Victor Cruz earned most of his points on one play this past weekend but nonetheless he’s still one of the most consistent receivers for the year. Larry Fitzgerald continues to prove that it doesn’t matter who the quarterback is, he’ll earn Fantasy points and Quality Games. He’s ranked fifth for the season and has an above average 67 percent QSR.

THE UNEXPECTED

Michael Crabtree could be a nice WR3 sleeper next season as he ended the season with five Quality Games out of his last six. Demaryius Thomas has earned four straight Quality Games and looks to be a favorite of Tim Tebow’s. Malcom Floyd earned his third Quality Game out of his last four and will always be a good pickup as long as he plays for San Diego.

Here is the list of top wide receivers that didn’t earn a Quality Game this week. There are a ton of big names on the bad list this week.

Rank Player
Team
Score
39 Pierre Garcon
IND
11.00
45 Santonio Holmes
NYJ
8.90
46 Santana Moss
WAS
8.60
54 Lance Moore
NO
7.30
55 Antonio Brown
PIT
7.20
58 A.J. Green
CIN
7.00
64 Vincent Jackson
SD
6.10
67 Brandon Lloyd
STL
5.90
79 Steve Smith
CAR
4.20
89 Hakeem Nicks
NYG
3.00

 

Consistency Leaders – YTD – Wide Receivers    

Player Name
Total Points
Rank
Total QG
Total GP
QSR
Calvin Johnson
318.80
2
14
15
93%
Mike Wallace
241.90
7
14
15
93%
Roddy White
266.70
3
13
15
87%
Greg Jennings
215.90
11
11
13
85%
Victor Cruz
259.10
4
11
14
79%
A.J. Green
213.40
14
11
14
79%
Wes Welker
324.80
1
11
15
73%
Percy Harvin
235.10
9
11
15
73%
Steve Johnson
204.40
18
11
15
73%
Hakeem Nicks
215.30
12
10
14
71%
Dez Bryant
196.30
20
10
14
71%
Marques Colston
207.80
16
9
13
69%
Laurent Robinson
183.70
22
9
13
69%
Larry Fitzgerald
245.20
5
10
15
67%
Steve Smith
244.30
6
10
15
67%
Jordy Nelson
241.10
8
10
15
67%
Brandon Marshall
229.70
10
10
15
67%
Dwayne Bowe
212.80
15
10
15
67%
Miles Austin
139.20
45
6
9
67%
Julio Jones
178.00
25
7
11
64%
Brandon Lloyd
174.60
26
9
14
63%
Nate Washington
205.60
17
9
15
60%
Santonio Holmes
166.10
28
9
15
60%
Jeremy Maclin
159.50
33
7
12
58%
Michael Crabtree
154.80
35
8
14
57%
Santana Moss
120.90
53
6
11
55%
Darrius Heyward-Bey
156.50
34
7
13
54%
Deion Branch
151.20
40
7
13
54%
Jabar Gaffney
184.90
21
8
15
53%
Antonio Brown
180.90
23
8
15
53%
Nate Burleson
162.80
30
8
15
53%
DeSean Jackson
162.60
32
7
14
50%
Vincent Jackson
214.70
13
7
15
47%
Mike Williams
154.30
36
7
15
47%
Eric Decker
150.80
41
7
15
47%

As we head to the last week of the season, the Mr. Consistency award at wide receiver is at an awkward spot. The leader in overall points is Wes Welker, however his QSR for the season is only 73 percent, while Calvin Johnson is ranked second overall and has a 93 percent QSR. Yeah, logic says Johnson, but if he doesn’t earn a Quality Game in Week 17, it’s going to be a tough vote. Roddy White may be 52 points behind Calvin in second place, but his consistency has earned him stud status in my book. Steve Johnson was supposed to possibly sit out due to a groin injury, but his toughness keeps his consistency high as he earned his 11th Quality Game of the season. 

 

Tight Ends – (Quality Game Factor – 8.87)

Quality Game Earners – Week 16  

Rank Player
Team
Score
1 Jared Cook
TEN
30.90
2 Brandon Pettigrew
DET
23.00
3 Jermaine Gresham
CIN
16.60
4 Dustin Keller
NYJ
15.70
5 Rob Gronkowski
NE
14.80
6 Evan Moore
CLE
14.50
7 Jimmy Graham
NO
14.20
8 Brent Celek
PHI
13.20
9 Kellen Winslow
TB
12.30
10 Kellen Davis
CHI
11.10
11 Jermichael Finley
GB
11.00
12 Kyle Rudolph
MIN
10.30
13 Daniel Fells
DEN
10.20
14 Ed Dickson
BAL
9.40
15 Jeremy Shockey
CAR
9.40
16 Vernon Davis
SF
9.40
17 Tony Gonzalez
ATL
9.10

THE EXPECTED

Stop the presses! There’s a non-Patriot tight end at the top of the list this week. This is un-American! Jared Cook followed up his big week last week with an even bigger week this week as he scored over 30 Fantasy points. Right behind him was Brandon Pettigrew, whose consistency has been average, but who has earned three straight Quality Games. Rob Gronkowski did earn a Quality Game this week, however Aaron Hernandez did not. Brent Celek kept up his hot streak as well with his seventh Quality Game out of his last nine games.

THE UNEXPECTED

Evan Moore snuck in with a rare Quality Game. Ok, it was his fourth of the year for those of you scoring at home. Daniel Fells also chimed in with his third Quality Game of the year. How about Jeremy Shockey with three straight Quality Games? Sorry, Greg Olsen, no Quality Games for you!  Look, Kyle Rudolph earned a Quality Game on Christmas Eve! Coincidence? Yeah, it was.

Here are the top tight ends that didn’t earn a Quality Game this week. Antonio Gates really hurt some Fantasy owners over the past two weeks with no Quality Games. Jason Witten also disappointed many Fantasy owners. 

Rank Player
Team
Score
18 Antonio Gates
SD
8.00
21 Aaron Hernandez
NE
7.70
25 Jason Witten
DAL
6.40
55 Greg Olsen
CAR
0.00
56 Visanthe Shiancoe
MIN
0.00

 

Consistency Leaders – YTD – Tight Ends

Player Name
Total Points
Rank
Total QG
Total GP
QSR
Jimmy Graham
271.30
2
14
15
93%
Rob Gronkowski
300.10
1
13
15
87%
Tony Gonzalez
207.70
3
13
15
87%
Aaron Hernandez
186.10
5
10
13
77%
Antonio Gates
162.20
7
9
12
75%
Jason Witten
189.30
4
10
15
67%
Fred Davis
155.30
11
8
12
67%
Brandon Pettigrew
172.10
6
9
15
60%
Jermichael Finley
160.30
9
9
15
60%
Jermaine Gresham
139.40
15
7
13
54%
Vernon Davis
160.90
8
8
15
53%
Dustin Keller
158.00
10
8
15
53%
Brent Celek
152.50
12
8
15
53%
Kellen Winslow
149.70
13
8
15
53%

Rob Gronkowski is the only tight end with over 300 points and he would be ranked third in overall points if he was a wide receiver. That’s insane! Jimmy Graham has earned 271.30 points and that would be ranked fourth behind Gronkowski. Graham still has the consistency title with one more Quality Game than Gronk. It will be very interesting to see where these two get drafted in next year’s Fantasy drafts. 

There’s your Week 16 list of Quality Games earned.

 

Week Seventeen – Quality Matchups

My Quality Game research has also shown that most Quality Games are earned during a Quality Matchup. This is a game where the player is either playing at home OR away versus a bottom ten defense. If you want more analysis to help with setting your lineup each week, check out the Xclusive Edge Package and you will see the Historical Consistency rankings each week.

 

So, let’s take a look at the schedule.

 

This week’s home teams are:

Philadelphia, Green Bay, Miami, New Orleans, St. Louis, Minnesota, Houston, Jacksonville, New England, Cleveland, Denver, Cincinnati, Arizona, Atlanta, Oakland and New York Giants.

 

Teams that are playing away versus a bottom ten defense include:

Detroit @ Green Bay

Buffalo @ New England

Dallas @ New York Giants

Carolina @ New Orleans

Chicago @ Minnesota

Kansas City @ Denver

 

As I mentioned above, the Fantasy players in these Quality Matchups have a much higher rate of performing above average in comparison to the other players at that position. 

 

If you have any questions about the Quality Game Scores, you can email me at blung@rotoexperts.com. You can also follow me on Twitter.

Get RotoExperts advice straight from your Android phone by downloading the app!

The best Roto news and advice comes straight to you from the RotoExperts right here!

Fantasy Football is in high gear and we’ve got you covered with live advice chats and e-mail advice. Sign up for the Xclusive Edge Playoff Fantasy Football package.

Wake up every morning with RotoExperts on Sirius XM’s Fantasy Sports Radio channel. Listen live starting at 7 am ET as RotoExperts.com covers all Fantasy Sports and takes your calls on Sirius channel 210 and XM channel 87.  Also, don’t forget, I’ll be on every Friday mornings at 9:30 am.

The best decision making tool is at Bloomberg Sports. Check it out here!

The Maxwell Football Club and RotoExperts are combining for a new Fantasy award and you can vote on it! Check it out here!

Get your pre-game updates on RotoExperts Dr. Roto’s Sunday morning radio show on 770 ESPN from 10 AM to 12 PM eastern.

Print Friendly