9. William Saliba - Arsenal FC
Arsenal did a lot of things really well in the 2024-2025 season: they went 15 games unbeaten, reached the Champions League semifinals, and finished second in the Premier League. Still, it’s fair to say there were some real missed opportunities. They lost in the third round of the FA Cup, bowed out to Newcastle in the Carabao Cup, and did not end up threatening Liverpool for the league title. There were several standout individual performances for the Gunners, including defender Gabriel Magalhaes (an argument could be made that he should have this spot). Still, William Saliba has more of a track record and gets the nod at No. 9. Arsenal only surrendered 34 league goals, the lowest number in the league. Saliba was rock solid all season in the center of the defense, and he’s always reliable for a good performance.